With... Adam Sargant
-
It's our last episode of series 1!!! Expect ghost, ghouls and lots of
laughs as we round off the series with Adam Sargant, AKA Haunted Haworth.
We'll be...
5 months ago
ENTERTAINING though the new BBC drama Jane Eyre might be, as a representation of Charlotte Bronte's famous novel it's a travesty. Some of the events from the original story are reasonably faithfully portrayed, but much of what is now being shown would be better described as new fiction by the screenwriter. The nature of the relationship between Jane and Rochester is pure 21st-century fantasy. The easy, playful banter that we witnessed in the closing scenes of the second episode is altogether unconvincing between any Victorian master and governess, and and at odds with the atmosphere Bronte created in her novel. And why does everyone persist in calling the heroine 'Missair'? Has every one of the actors failed to notice that the spelling is Eyre? The BBC must think today's viewers incapable of watching a period drama unless its characters are mutated into 21st-century caricatures. JENNIFER McNALLY, Dundee. (c) 2006 Daily Mail.This half of BrontëBlog agrees with the reviewer, but with different conclusions. Each new Jane Eyre is an ADAPTATION. We have the literary original and I, personally, don't need a faithful reproduction of the original. Firstly, it would be pointless (if we have the original, do we really need a photocopy?) and secondly it would be impossible (I think it was David Cronenberg who said that the only way you could faithfully adapt a book it's filming page by page the actual book) : TV, movies and books are different arts. Each adaptation should be faithful to the spirit of the novel, but it's a product of its time. And there's nothing wrong with that.
Rare among such ventures, the imagined prequel to Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre, which is set in colonial Jamaica and tells the story of Mr Rochester's arranged marriage, won some critical acclaim. It was named by Time Magazine as one of the 100 best English language novels since 1923.
IT'S OFFICIAL: Dorset's women prefer Mr Darcy to Mr Rochester - well those voting in our website poll do at least.And finally, Richard Wilcocks of the Brontë Parsonage Blog writes about some recent ghosts activities (Most Haunted people, what are you waiting for?) near the Parsonage itself.
We asked online readers whether they preferred Jane Austen's Darcy or Charlotte Bronte's Rochester and 72 per cent picked the hero of Pride & Prejudice.
Perhaps it has something to do with the psychics who were invited into the Parsonage by Cornelia Parker so that their voices could be recorded for her current exhibition Brontëan Abstracts. It is now possible to listen to their conversations on headphones which are installed in several rooms. Quite a few visitors cross Church Street after their tour of the Museum to take a look at the Matt Lamb exhibition -Spirits of the Brontë Sisters - which fills the School Room.Do you want to know what they saw? Check the post :P.
The fact is that some of them may have seen a ghost, or think they have, according to the eminently down-to-earth Peter Ashton, the man in charge there.
0 comments:
Post a Comment