Podcasts

  • With... Bethany Turner-Pemberton - Sassy and Sam chat to researcher and curator Bethany Turner-Pemberton. Bethany is PhD candidate in Textiles and Museum Studies at Manchester Metropolitan...
    1 day ago

Friday, May 09, 2008

Friday, May 09, 2008 1:42 pm by M. in ,    8 comments
Frantic days for the Brontë film adaptations. Some weeks ago we reported the attachment of Natalie Portman to a new Wuthering Heights film project and a few days ago it was Ellen Page who was presented as the new Jane Eyre in another BBC Films project. And now it seems that finally Natalie Portman won't be Cathy after all. Michael Fassbender (in the picture) has been approached to play Heathcliff. The Daily Mail reports:

Hollywood star Natalie Portman has walked out of a big-screen version of Wuthering Heights, throwing the production into chaos.

Her decision to withdraw from the British film has infuriated its backers because, far from being wooed for the role, she actively pursued the plum part of Emily Bronte's tragic heroine Cathy Earnshaw.

The movie's director John Maybury and producers Ecosse Films and HanWay were blinded by Portman's dazzling "come-on". Neither film company would comment yesterday.

Portman pursued the part vigorously and was so passionate about it that she asked for and received casting approval for Heathcliff.

An insider on the film said: "It's fair to say we were seduced by her and we should have been on our guard."

Frankly, many (particularly this column) doubted Portman's suitability to play one of the most fascinating characters in English literature.

In fact, before Portman arrived on the scene, Maybury had told me he preferred a British actress to play the part, because he felt an American wouldn't get the accent right.

Indeed, a British accent has never been Portman's strong suit — as evidenced by her peculiar pronunciation in The Other Boleyn Girl, where she sounded, to my ears anyway, distinctly colonial.

Portman's decision to walk away from Wuthering Heights will teach British filmmakers a valuable lesson, principally that they shouldn't just go after a "name" for commercial reasons.

Interestingly, Ellen Page, of Juno fame, has just landed the title role in a BBC Film version of Jane Eyre, as much for financial reasons as artistic. But I happen to sense that Page is right for Eyre, whereas Portman would have been dodgy for Wuthering Heights.

There are plenty of quality British actresses who can play Cathy, from Andrea Riseborough, who is brilliant as the young Margaret Thatcher in the forthcoming BBC drama The Long Walk To Finchley, to Emily Blunt (so good in The Devil Wears Prada), Sienna Miller and Keira Knightley.

Miller and Knightley, by the way, star in Maybury's movie The Edge Of Love, which opens next month's Edinburgh Film Festival. The director has coaxed the best screen work to date — particularly in the film's last third — from these two often underrated actresses.

Cameras aren't due to roll on Wuthering Heights till the autumn, so there's still time to cast the right person for Cathy (which rules out Scarlett Johansson).

The job will require tact, though — will Ms Knightley, for instance, want to take Natalie Portman's leftovers? Meanwhile, actor Michael Fassbender is being talked about to play Heathcliff. (Baz Bamigboye)

By the way, remember the Mammoth Screen Wuthering Heights project? We have received some hints that the production is quite alive and well. They're planning to shoot in Yorkshire in five weeks. The ITV airing will be probably around the end of year. Let's wait and see.

Categories: ,

8 comments:

  1. I've got to admit i'm slightly annoyed by this. Considering she pursued the part, it's very odd to back out now. I hope this doesn't do significant damge to the production. At least now a Brit might get the role. Bloody best not be Lilo though.

    So, the ITV one might go ahead after all? In five weeks? Has it not been cast yet? Micheal Fassbender would be quite good actually.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well, I'll just come out and say it. I'm thrilled and extremely relieved to hear Natalie Portman won't be playing Cathy. Her accent was dreadful in "V for Vendetta" - so much so that it spoiled an otherwise brilliant film (for me, at least, and I'm American). I hope that her departure leaves the door wide open for a Brit. I am keeping my fingers crossed for Emily Blunt, who is fantastic in everything she does. I think she has the intensity necessary to play Catherine in spades.

    Now I'm just waiting to hear that Ellen Page as Jane is just someone's idea of a bad joke...

    ReplyDelete
  3. Faye - I find it very weird that the publicised it so much without her having signed a contract and made it definitive. I just hope this won't take us back to Lindsay Lohan :P

    Yep, the ITV production is alive and well. No word on the cast just yet, though.

    Anonymous - I had made up my mind to Natalie Portman and wasn't finding it too terrible. We will see who's next - hopefully not Lindsay Lohan as I was saying to Faye!

    Much as I like Emily Blunt as an actress I don't really see her as VCathy to be honest.

    I was wondering yesterday if the Ellen Page thing wouldn't end up the same way Natalie Portman's has. Fingers crossed or not?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I wouldn't be suprised if Emily Blunt got it and i wouldn't be dissapointed either. She's played some Cathyesque characters in the past and has played them very, very well.

    This was on the Daily 10 this morning. They also said Michael Fassbender is in final talks to play Heathcliff so i'll be suprised if he doesn't end up with the part.

    I'm still to bewildered by the Ellen/Jane thing to comment.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I couldn't say what it is at this moment that keeps me from thinking Emily Blunt would make a good Cathy. It's just a feeling, I suppose. I know she's a good actress, though. So we will see if she's offered the part and takes it.

    Thanks for the info on Michael Fassbender. Too bad his Cathy is gone even before it all began.

    Faye, do take your time to let the Ellen/Jane thing sink. We know it's not easy :P

    ReplyDelete
  6. Cristina what do you think of Hayley Atwell for Cathy? I like Michael a lot by the way.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I come bearing news. I'm not sure how reliable this is but... It has casting news about the ITV version:

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/1944660/Two-new-takes-on-Bronte's-ill-fated-love-tale.html?source=rss

    ReplyDelete
  8. Faye - Ooh! Great suggestion! I really would love to see Hayley Atwell playing Cathy. Wish she actually did...

    You got it right with Michael!

    Anonymous - Many thanks for the link. As you will have seen we have posted it above.

    ReplyDelete