Podcasts

  • S4 E8: With... Rebecca Marks - For the final episode of series 4, Sam and Mia are joined by historian, author and content creator Dr Rebecca Marks! Rebecca holds a Master's in Art Hist...
    1 month ago

Sunday, November 22, 2026

Sunday, November 22, 2026 11:23 am by Cristina in , , , , , , ,    No comments
New York Classical Review has an article on Carlisle Floyd's Wuthering Heights opera and its current revival in New York.
The admirable production of Wuthering Heights by the little OPERA theatre of ny at the Sheen Center on Bleecker Street marks the composer’s 100th anniversary year and is the first viewing here since New York City Opera presented it in 1959. Friday night’s double-cast performance featured Sara Kennedy, a lyric soprano with an appropriately scary top, as Cathy Earnshaw, who becomes Cathy Linton, and who in her heart wishes she were Cathy Heathcliff.
All opera adaptations of novels, especially this novel, prune away huge branches of plot to get to a story that’s tellable in an evening of music. Crafting his own libretto for a story where one of the turning points is a card game, Floyd stacked the deck for Cathy. He gave some nice moments to the other characters—almost, it seemed, as a favor to the singers—before getting on to his main concern: Cathy’s innocence, Cathy’s wishes, Cathy’s inner conflicts, Cathy’s rage, Cathy’s desperation.
Unfortunately, it wasn’t always easy to tell exactly what or when those things were, as the usual opera aids—supertitles, a synopsis of Floyd’s version of the story—were absent. The company took a chance that the singers’ clear English diction would carry the day, but it didn’t. One found oneself, especially in the opera’s dialogue-heavy second half, looking at Cathy’s body language or other characters’ reactions to her for clues to what was going on. 
Opera in English for an English-speaking audience is a great thing, but not if the vocal tessitura makes it unintelligible. The melos of Susannah came from Appalachian folk tunes; Puccini was the nearest reference point for Wuthering Heights, with results that were often dramatic or pretty, but hard to understand.
One could, however, still admire Floyd’s way with a musical phrase, how the rhythm and shape of English could become attractive music, which might even slip into actual speech now and then without one’s noticing.
As the headstrong Cathy, soprano Kennedy was winsome in the early going and fiery later on, as her character was buffeted by the expectations of society in Regency England. The singer passed all Floyd’s tests of stamina as the composer took her repeatedly into the vocal stratosphere to express passion or derangement.
In fact, high notes were on offer everywhere in this score, to the point of seeming gratuitous in such a domestic drama. Friday’s cast, however, was only too happy to display its vocal equipment, especially tenor Spencer Hamlin as Cathy’s irascible brother Hindley. (You’d hit a few high notes too if you’d just lost the family estate in a card game to that schemer Heathcliff.)
Compared to his role in the literary source, the character of Heathcliff was present here only in outline: Cathy’s childhood companion, later her lover, the dirty ragamuffin who disappeared for years only to return as a wealthy man of the world with dark designs on the Earnshaw and Linton families.
In the interest of his romantic story, Floyd soft-pedaled those designs and emphasized Cathy and Heathcliff’s carefree romps in the Yorkshire moors, vividly depicted in this production with video projections by Alex Basco Koch and Stephanie Beattie that wrapped around the auditorium.
Heathcliff with his fangs removed was dramatically and vocally no match for Floyd’s Cathy, and baritone Wayne Hu, despite a well-focused voice and convincing stage presence as both the downtrodden and the confident Heathcliff, wasn’t entirely able to close that gap.
Although Cathy was drawn to the elegant ways of the Lintons, who lived in the fancy house down in the valley, they didn’t excite composer Floyd as much as the turbulent Earnshaws on the heights. Still, the composer threw them a couple of juicy bones: tenor Ryan Allais as Edgar Linton soared in his marriage proposal to Cathy (her response, spoken: “Yes, I will marry you.”) and soprano Teresa Castillo as Edgar’s sister Isabella rhapsodized with plenty of high notes at the prospect of marriage to Heathcliff.
Observing this marriage-go-round with increasing dismay was the Earnshaws’ housekeeper Nelly, confidante to both Cathy and Heathcliff, a warm voice of reason amid the opera’s crazy passions. Margaret Lattimore’s rich mezzo-soprano in the role brought relief from all the high notes and a firm core to duets and ensembles, while her acting skills gave the character memorable detail and presence.
Solid if brief characterizations came from the sturdy bass Bert K. Johnson as Cathy’s ailing father, tenor David Gordon as the Earnshaws’ fussy old servant Joseph, and tenor Chad Kranak as Lockwood, a neighbor frightened by a vision—or was it a dream?—of Cathy’s ghost in the opera’s prologue.
Conductor Richard Cordova supported Floyd’s continuous vocal lines assiduously with an orchestra that was a little too light on strings to achieve the composer’s more atmospheric effects. The late-Romantic dissonances of 1958 may have been supplemented by some 2026 vagaries in the woodwinds here and there.
Director Philip Shneidman used the small proscenium stage resourcefully to maintain visual interest without excessive criss-cross blocking for the singers. In Claire Karoff’s economical scenic design, the suspended outlines of a window, a fireplace, etc. sufficed to suggest the opera’s country-house settings. 
The Regency costumes by Lara De Bruijn shone especially in the party scene, with social dances of the period elegantly choreographed by Elizabeth Roxas-Dobrish. (The ensemble of nine party guests danced and sang a charming chorus as well.) Nick Solyom’s lighting design lit the singers well and subtly reinforced the mood of the moment throughout the opera.
Now, regarding Floyd’s adaptation of Brontë’s novel, here is Spoiler One: Before her marriage to Edgar, Cathy gives in to her desire and (apparently) does the deed with Heathcliff. At least, they have a “Gone With the Wind” moment where he sweeps her up in his arms and carries her upstairs as the curtain falls. Very romantic, but it turns everything afterward from a 19th-century tantalizing story of sexual repression into a 21st-century embarrassing old-boyfriend situation.
Spoiler Two: Floyd neatly disposes of the whole next-generation part of the novel by having pregnant Cathy expire in Heathcliff’s arms–as they gaze out at their beloved moor—before she gives birth instead of after. But the death of a pregnant mother-to-be hardly seems like the stuff of romance. Couldn’t Floyd at least have let her have the baby before the star-crossed lovers had their moor moment? (David Wright)
According to Collider, Wuthering Heights 2009 is 'Tom Hardy's 142-Minute Near-Perfect Miniseries which 'Has Not Been Beaten' yet.
The 2009 limited series does justice to her vast scope, truncates little, and softens nothing. Writer Peter Bowker achieves maximum faithfulness, preserving the thematic integrity in general and by including the crucial plot beats other adaptations abandon for the sake of streamlined simplicity; eliminating the second generation of children negates Brontë's prevailing points. Bowker's scripts employ a flashback structure instead of a traditional chronological approach, which prevents the second episode from losing momentum and gives both halves equal weight.
Coky Giedroyc's direction might not contain the same level of moody lavishness as a high-budget Hollywood affair, but for 2009-era network television, the atmosphere is precisely on point. By day, the visuals luxuriate in the windswept and rocky Yorkshire Moors like the terrain is a private paradise; by night, those same locations drip with an ominous, rain-soaked, Gothic chill no warm coat or feeble lantern light can protect against. If anything, the production's subtle efficiency enables the performers to sell the emotional turbulence with maximum artistic freedom and commitment.
In a way, Heathcliff is a perfect example of Hardy both playing against type and tapping into his exact strengths. It's a demanding role, and he unearths the complete spectrum — every paradoxical layer of aching loneliness, tender desperation, wounded pride, extreme intelligence, seething spite, and punitive cruelty. A defiant survivor of abuse, ostracization, and rejection, he's understated and internalized at one moment, his eyes hollowed out by the phantoms of regret, before gliding straight into visceral rage. He can invade and dominate a room through the sheer force of his insidious physicality, yet still exert a seductively appealing gravitational pull.
And a Heathcliff, of course, is nothing without his beloved Cathy Earnshaw (Charlotte Riley). Another exceedingly intricate and tricky role, Riley makes Cathy as irresistible, isolated, selfish, jealous, and demanding as she should be. The woman's whims are as untethered as the wind and as dangerous as a sparking live wire; she relishes exerting control by playfully toying with her lovers. In tandem, Riley sells the overwhelming sincerity of Cathy's volatile emotions; it's readily apparent and tragic why her gilded-cage aristocratic life kills her unsatiated spirit long before it kills her body. The war between her contradictory desires — liberated freedom versus conforming to society's standards for financial security and comfort — plays across her face like an Expressionist painting.
Hardy and Riley's chemistry is so naturally thunderous that the pair married five years after filming Wuthering Heights. They capture the characters' star-crossed toxicity in all its smothering closeness, from two young and powerless outcasts who forge a home together and consume each other's chaotic passion like oxygen, to venomous snakes inflicting reciprocal misery until both parties self-destruct. Cathy and Heathcliff is no great love story by any aspirational or enviable measure. However, as terrible, damaged, and lost people who recognize their twin flame, but ruin the solace for which they yearn, they're perfect for each other — as near-perfect as this masterpiece adaptation. (Kelcie Mattson)
This columnist from USA Today is one of those using Wuthering Heights 2026 as a benchmark.
I approach book adaptations with trepidation. It's all too common to feel utter disappointment when our favorite books hit the screens, especially when they're unable to translate what it felt like to live in that beloved fictional world. This year has seen much of that, in this reader's humble opinion. (Cough cough, "Wuthering Heights.") (Clare Mulroy)
El placer de la lectura (Spain) recommends the recently-published Spanish collection of translations of Emily Brontë's poems. According to Metropolitan Magazine (Italy) Jane Eyre is the book of the week for Libras.

0 comments:

Post a Comment