'I think the Brontë sisters are mad'

The Red House story (sign the petition here) continues being featured in local newspapers such as the Yorkshire Post:

The world-renowned Brontë Society says the proposal to close Red House Museum at Gomersal is “an act of vandalism on the local tourist industry”.
The society’s former chairman, Richard Wilcocks, said: “A cut like this would cause irreparable damage, and an important part of the heritage of the Spen Valley and the whole country would be lost.
“Red House is of crucial importance not only for those dismissed in the (council’s) official impact statement as ‘Brontë enthusiasts’, a choice of words which implies that they make up a minor group in the same league as train-spotters, but for anyone who believes that the most fitting memorial to Mary Taylor, a highly significant historical figure, not only because of her lifelong friendship with Charlotte Brontë, is the museum situated in her house.
“Perhaps that should be national memorial – let’s move beyond the parochial.”
Director of the Brontë Parsonage at Haworth, Andrew McCarthy, said Red House attracted about 30,000 visitors a year, “quite good for a museum off the beaten track”.
He urged Brontë enthusiasts to write to Kirklees Council.
Councillors will discuss the budget cuts at a meeting on February 22 but members of the public can have their say at a public meeting tonight (from 7pm) at Cleckheaton Town Hall.
A council spokesman said: “Councillors have difficult decisions to make as there is a continuing need to achieve efficiencies from across the whole range of services in the three-year budget plan.
“The proposal to close Red House Museum is one of a large number of measures up for consideration which have been proposed to fill a very big gap in the council’s budget and reduce expenditure. No decision has been made yet.”
Submit views via communication@kirklees.gov.uk
To date over 100 emails and letters have been received.

This is not a 'difficult decision to make'. It's just a silly, self-damaging decision. Good for the 100 letters an emails, though - keep those coming and get as many people as possible to sign the petition.

The story has also reached a national newspaper: the Guardian.

One of the major shrines to the Brontë family is facing closure and sale because of budget cuts and recession – a combination that almost did for its wealthy owner in the days of Charlotte, Emily and Anne.
The Red House in Gomersal, in West Yorkshire's "heavy woollen district", is targeted in provisional savings drawn up by Kirklees district council, which is having to find savings of £64m in what councillors describe as "the most difficult financial landscape in living memory".
The proposal has triggered uproar led by the Brontë Society which is appealing for supporters to lobby the council to change its mind. The Red House, a handsome early Georgian mansion built of brick in the largely millstone grit area between Huddersfield, Dewsbury and Bradford, played a significant part in Charlotte Brontë's youth. [...]
The director of the Brontë Parsonage at Haworth, Andrew McCarthy, said the proposal had come as a shock, along with other suggested cuts including reduced hours at Oakwell Hall, another Kirklees museum that plays an important part in Shirley.
"We appreciate the challenges faced by local authorities in terms of balancing the budgets at the moment but this does seem a pretty drastic step that can be made in haste and repented at leisure," he said. "There are very few buildings which combine Brontë history and Brontë fiction in the way Red House does. It would be a huge loss."
A petition has also been launched to present to the council, which is not controlled by any one party and has seen cross-party negotiations over the coming budget. Kirklees's wellbeing and communities directorate, whose portfolio includes museums, has to make 19% savings from £129m spent last year to £105m. Councillors will decide the issue on 22 February.
Closure of the Red House in September would make a full-year saving of £116,000 with sale of the site an additional, one-off capital receipt, probably of around £750,000. The museum has won a raft of prizes, from Sandford educational awards to Loo of the Year, but drew only 28,602 visitors last year and fewer than 1,000 children in school parties.
Taylor almost lost the house himself in 1826 when his private bank went under without any hope of a government buyout to help it. He recovered by dint of his own efforts and a reputation, also ascribed to Yorke in Shirley, for helping his own workers find alternatives when his mill was forced into lay-offs during a recession. (Martin Wainwright)

The blog Secluded Charm is appalled by the story.

The Telegraph reports adapter Andrew Davies's thoughts on the Brontës:

He told an audience at the Hay Festival in Cartagena, Colombia: “I’ve declined quite a few – never classics. I’m glad nobody has asked me to adapt Wuthering Heights because I think I would make a mess of it. Everybody makes a mess of it. I think the Brontë sisters are mad. [...]" (Anita Singh)

The writer Ruskin Bond seems to have a more favourable opinion. He says to The Hindu,

“I still like going back to old favourites. I read ‘Wuthering Heights' as a boy and loved it. When I picked it up again, many years later, it kept me up all night! I wanted to be a writer even before I finished school. David Copperfield became a role model. I wanted to, like him, run away from home, but I didn't have much pocket money left to do that!” (Sravasti Datta)

This columnist from TIME Magazine hasn't read The Tenant of Wildfell Hall:

It’s dawning on me that the marriage plot, which maps so well onto novels by Austen and the Brontës and George Eliot, is misapplied to Dickens. It is far more productive to think of him as a writer of would-be divorce plots. (Radhika Jones)

The Telegraph also thinks that Jonathan Franzen, despite his battle against ebooks, doesn't know much about them:

I have to admit I don't understand this argument. Does he think that e-publishers will surreptitiously edit classic works? Perhaps sprinkle Beowulf with Starbucks adverts, or weave party political messages subtly into the text of Jane Eyre? In all honesty, I suspect that this is an example of a very clever man using his considerable brainpower to dress up unconscious prejudice in what sounds like reasoned argument. Mr Franzen doesn't like e-books; he prefers reading books. But he can't simply say as much, so he wraps it in a layer of talk about "permanence" and "responsible self-government". There's an analogy somewhere with an octopus squirting out a cloud of ink to cover its escape. (Tom Chivers)

Alt Film Guide comments on tonight's broadcast of Jane Eyre 1944 on TCM (US, see sidebar)

Jane Eyre has been made and remade about a zillion times in the last century or so. Fontaine's version, directed by Robert Stevenson (later of Mary Poppins fame) and co-starring Orson Welles as Rochester, used to be the most famous one. (At least for the time being, Cary Fukunaga's well-received 2011 version starring Mia Wasikowska and Michael Fassbender has become "the most famous" Jane Eyre movie.) Unfortunately, despite veteran George Barnes' moody cinematography, Stevenson's version isn't nearly as involving as Charlotte Brontë's novel.
Fontaine is okay in the title role, but her heart doesn't seem to be totally in the part. Worse yet, Welles' Rochester comes across as more creepy than brooding. It's too bad that Michael Fassbender wasn't around in the mid-'40s; he'd have been a much more adequate Rochester/Fontaine match. Aldous Huxley, by the way, was one of the film's credited screenwriters. (Andre Soares)

A reader of The Telegraph and Argus comments on installing wind turbines in the Bradford area:

Far from being a ‘blot’ (T&A. January 28), wind turbines could regenerate Bradford.
Of course they should not be planted next to the Cow and Calf or the Brontë Parsonage. Turbines should be at a suitable distance, but near, our built-up areas. [...]
John D Anderson, Bramham Drive, Baildon

The Brussels Brontë Blog posts about Andrea Arnold's Wuthering Heights. Loud and Little and Cicero (in German) discuss Jane Eyre. Where the Moon Sleeps shows pictures of a gorgeous edition of Shirley.