The
Yorkshire Post reviews the recent concert by the Orchestra of Opera North which included the premiere of the
Gypsy Dance piece from Frédéric Chaslin's opera
Wuthering Heights:
They rallied to give a lustrous and sensual account of Debussy’s L’après
midi d’un faune, and did their best with the stodgily orchestrated and
unengaging neo-romantic Gypsy Dance from Chaslin’s own opera Wuthering
Heights. (Chris Robbins)
Neo-romantic it is, as to stodgily we don't know as we haven't heard the orchestrated version but unengaging we assure you it is not.
The Halifax Courier recommends
Jane Eyre 2011:
[C]ostume dramas never seem to go out of fashion and one of the most
famous is the brooding romanticism in Jane Eyre, penned by Charlotte
Brontë.
The Dumfries Standard reviews the film:
There is a rawness to the landscape and the grim walls of Thornfield Hall that sends a chill across the film.
Mia Wasikowska was an insipid Alice thanks to Tim Burton but here
the Australian actress shows far more depth of character in her
restrained but convincing performance as the abused, introverted but
stoical heroine.
Michael Fassbender is a rugged Rochester and there is the familiar
delight of Judi Dench as Mrs Fairfax with strong support from Jamie Bell
as the frustrated St John Rivers who proclaims love for Jane but is
cruelly spurned.
This Jane is no pushover.
Worksop Guardian:
It’s rare for a film to hold my complete attention for two hours but
this one did. Both Wasikowska and Fassbender held the screen
magnificently and I didn’t want the story to end.
Even if period
dramas aren’t normally your thing, I would recommend going to see it
because this love story remains as powerful today as it was when Brontë
wrote it. (Helen Johnston)
And
HeyYouGuys.co.uk:
Director Cary Fukunaga ensured the film remained true to the novel and
time period, sticking faithfully to Brontë’s plot, including almost
every key literary moment so fans of the novel felt that the symbolism
and power of the original were kept intact. For a modern cinematic
audience, however, this is not enough, and Fukunaga uses subtle camera
techniques that keep Jane Eyre up to date and fresh for today’s
audience. In particular the scene in which Jane discovers the secret
door leading to Bertha’s chamber, with its extreme close ups and
dramatic contrast between dark and light the shot was reminiscent of
modern horror films. Using conventions such as these, Fukunaga manages
to give an audience unfamiliar with Brontë’s work a sense of familiarity,
making this Victorian plot accessible to all. (Guest)
The Italian release of the movie is next week and Paperblog has posts with
reviews,
reading groups and
giveaways.
Everyeye,
Primissima and
Il Giornale di Vicenza also publish reviews. The Polish release will be in October 14 and
Plejada,
dziennik,
eMuzyka,
students.pl,
onet,
Deon,
Łódź - Gazeta talk about it.
Kvällstidningen Expressen (Sweden) has an article about the film and the other previous adaptations, including the Swedish theatrical version premiered last year.
Several Dutch reviews can be found on
De Nieuwe Utrechter,
Boeken,
Spits Nieuws,
ED.nl,
NU.nl,
De Telegraaf and
OpReidsGids recommends a visit to Yorkshire.
At
The Southern Reporter the subject is Haddon Hall:
That night in my bedroom, I could hear long skirts rustle across the floor near the end of my bed – I was, at 10, terrified.
Such acute imagination should be
expected when you have read Jane Eyre and are in the first few chapters
of Wuthering Heights. Even before I left primary school, my head was
filled with the dark and passionate love portrayed in the Brontes’
novels. (...) On the day of my visit, there was a great deal of activity as the hall
prepared to receive guests to watch a premiere of the new Jane Eyre
film. For the third time, Haddon Hall will be Thornfield where the
unusual love affair of Jane and Mr Rochester will be acted out for our
insatiable love of this classic tale.
Sabotage Times has something to say about
Wuthering Heights 2011 and the Brontë cult (including the Haworth graveyard, clampers, Japanese tourists and Top Withens):
British director Andrea Arnold has broken new ground by casting an
unknown black actor in the role of Heathcliff and swapping breathless
clinches for gratuitous sex scenes. Coupled with the kind of language
that would make Malcolm Tucker blush, it’s fair to say it might ruffle a few petticoats.
Set in the rugged moorland of the Worth Valley – a place I’m proud to
call home – Wuthering Heights is not an easy read and for commercial
reasons many productions have shied away from some of its darker
complexities. Despite some mixed reviews Arnold’s version sounds like
it’s attempted to redress the balance between those that have been more
withering than Wuthering. (...)
Writing under the pen name of a man – because women weren’t meant to do
much other than press flowers and produce litters of sickly runts, Emily
Brontë wove together a dark and complex tale that belied her age and
experience. As a reclusive virgin it’s staggering to imagine her first
and only novel is a “Russian Doll” of a tale with multiple narrators,
time shifts and intricately incestuous plots. It even visits the clammy
world of necrophilia in one memorable scene where Heathcliff
desperately attempts to dig up his lover’s rotting corpse for one last
roll in the heather. (Read more) (Jonathan Lorrimer)
The film will enter competition at the Seminci 2011 (Valladolid, Spain) (22-29 October).
The
QMI Agency reviews
The Reinvention of Love by Helen Humphreys:
Helen Humphreys' new novel follows a recent trend toward fashioning fiction from the lives of the celebrated.
Such
books as Becoming Jane Eyre, Becoming George Sand, Becoming Jane Austen
and Daphne, a mosaic featuring Daphne du Maurier and the Brontë
sisters, have won wide readerships. (Nancy Schiefer)
Michelle Rowe made a trip to England and publishes her experiences, including a visit to Haworth, in
The Australian:
At the parsonage we see the dining room and small table around which
Charlotte, Emily and Anne did much of their writing, and Charlotte's
bedroom, with her wedding bonnet and veil, writing desk and contents,
black evening pumps and trinket box among the items on display.
We
learn about the Brontës' ne'er-do-well brother Branwell, an alcoholic
who died at 31, regretting that all his life he "had done nothing either
great or good" (his sisters were surely a hard act to follow). Also on
display is a devastating review of Charlotte Brontë's Jane Eyre
published in The Quarterly Review, which incensed the eldest Brontë
sister.
The Parent Paper talks about vampires, zombies and teenagers:
For even more of a twist on classic literature, more mature teens might
want to give some of the recent horror-classic mash-ups a try. Two that
stand out in this fast-growing body of books is Seth Grahame-Smith’s
rework of Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice and Zombies and Jane Slayre
by Sherri Browning Erwin, based on Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre.
Following the original plot of both classics, including a lot of the
actual text, the new works just add the zombie and vampire elements into
the story to explain the action and motives of the characters. Most
readers will want to know a little about the classic work, but I’m told
by readers who have not read the originals that it’s not absolutely
necessary. (Pat Vasilik)
CNN's Geek Out talks with Janet Lee about her Jane Austen Marvel comic adaptations:
While author Nancy Butler was in charge of spinning Austen’s wordy
text into five digestible installments, Lee had to bring the world of
Miss Woodhouse to life.
“‘Emma’ is a happier story,” she said. “For all of her faults, she’s
just apple pie. We wanted to do sort of a bright, pastel, candy-tone
kind of feel in the illustration. ‘Northanger [Abbey]’ is making fun of Gothic
literature, so you really want it to be more Brontë-esque, on the moors
with a hand-to-forehead feel.” (Ashley Strickland)
New Statesman suggests the creation of Enemybook:
Keep enemies close to by staying up-to-date on their family holidays and favourite pastimes. Is Jane Eyre their new favourite book? Maybe you should write as your status that you hate it. Instead of a poke, why not gouge? (Androulla Harris)
The Skinny describes like this a performance in the latest episode of
The X-Factor:
Wendy Davis (Penfold from Dangermouse in a dress) presented a Wuthering-Heights-themed PSA on ‘buying stronger locks for laboratory doors.' (Fred Fletch)
Movie Line reviews the film
Dream House :
Actually, it may help to think of Dream House
as a [Douglas] Sirk movie of sorts, with maybe a little Emily Brontë mixed in —
it doesn’t exactly work as a thriller, and not because [Jim] Sheridan and his
actors don’t try. (Stephanie Zacharek)
Ria Novosti (in Spanish) talks about the feminism in
Jane Eyre:
Esta novela suelen llamarla uno de los primeros textos literarios
feministas del mundo. No estoy segura de que Jane Eyre de verdad fuera
una feminista, pero poseía ciertas cualidades, que adoptaron las
activistas de derechos de la mujer a finales del siglo XX. Era
impaciente pero objetiva, franca y ferozmente independiente. Rechazaba
los fastuosos regalos con los que la intentaba colmar su novio y ella
quería seguir trabajando de institutriz después de la boda para ser
económicamente independiente. Además, expresaba abiertamente sus
convicciones que eran bastante radicales para aquel tiempo. (Svetlana Kolchik) (Translation)
Fotogramas (Spain) reviews
Wuthering Heights 2011:
La estupenda adaptación de Cumbres Borrascosas a cargo de la británica Andrea Arnold, un prodigio de fisicidad y naturalismo que insufla modernidad al clásico de Emily Brontë, más sensorial que nunca , romántico como siempre. (Manuel Yáñez Murillo) (Translation)
Kate Walker's
The Return of the Stranger is initiating a blog tour with posts on
Talli Roland,
Romance Book Paradise,
Kylie Griffin and
Lucy Monroe.
Le Devoir (Canada) announces the upcoming (next Monday, October 3) airing of
Les Soeurs Brontë 1979 in TFO:
Après une projection désastreuse à Cannes en 1979, le film, qui durait
trois heures, fut amputé d'un peu plus d'une heure, ce qui explique sans
doute les quelques ellipses brutales et autres cassures narratives qui minent la version remontée. Tout cela ne devrait
pas décourager le cinéphile de voir Les Soeurs Brontë au moins une
fois, la vue étant pour le compte le seul sens réellement sollicité par
cette oeuvre splendide, mais inachevée. (François Levesque) (Translation)
The Guardian quotes the first paragraph of the new novel by Jeffrey Eugenides,
The Marriage Plot in its review. The Brontë mention can be read in this
previous post of ours; on
Pajamas Media the author rediscovered Jane Eyre after skipping in high school;
Otago Daily Times describes James Taylor as the Heathcliff of folk rock;
Virtual Lancaster reviews
We are Three Sisters;
Life in the Slow Lane and
daydreamers,
Språkkärringen's Blog (both in Swedish) review
Jane Eyre 2011;
Musings of an Endless Dimension posts about Haworth and the Brontës;
Pensamentos de uma Batata Transgênica posts about the history of the Portuguese translations of
Jane Eyre. Ángeles Caso visits the National Portrait Gallery and the Pillar Portrait in
La Vanguardia (Spain).
The kind of comments like the one in the Sabotage Times article, in which they once again state that it's staggering that a "reclusive virgin" could write a book like Wuthering Heights, are quite patronising, if not insulting, and I wish people would stop assuming to know exactly what kind of person Emily was. I even doubt her sisters knew.
ReplyDeleteAt the time of the publication of WH I can comprehend the astonishment of linking a woman like Emily Brontë--or a woman, period--to such a dark and out-of-the-norm book. Nowadays we should be able to understand people with a broader perspective, but if there's going to be an insistence on a superficial and old-fashioned analysis of the author, I can only bring out some good ol' fashioned feminism.
Speaking of Haddon Hall, they had a Behind the Scenes event of Jane Eyre '11 today, which I attended. (Currently in the process of uploading the photos, which is taking forEVER!) They're having another one on 23 October as well, if other people are interested. Tickets are £11.50 and you need to book them in advance. Well worth it, though! :) They have some of the costumes on display in the Long Gallery, and they show you around all the places where they filmed in the house (including some not normally open to the public) and tell anectotes from the filming.
ReplyDelete