Sunday, May 11, 2008
Categories: In the News, Jane Eyre, Movies-DVD-TVAll the fuss about Ellen Page being cast as Jane Eyre for a BBC film is misplaced. I think she's got the part because she's a really good actress and the producers must think she's the best person for the part. Not to cast on the basis of her being the wrong nationality would be mad. Page has shown her range not only in Juno, but also in her breakout role in Hard Candy, where she played a young girl with an internet stalker who is not as innocent as she seems.
I think we, the British, feel very proprietorial about Jane Eyre, and the fact that people associate Page with a very young culture is another hurdle for them to get over to allow her to be a classical heroine – but I reckon she's got a lot more than just the Juno string to her bow. She can really act.
In terms of casting for major films, the world is a tiny place these days and the film industry is international. For casting directors, it's natural to look wider than just within Britain. (...) (Read more)
It maybe easier to play Jane Eyre than a contemporary British character because there's a cultural foundation. It's not just about the accent; there's a whole culture to absorb and put into the character. However, there are challenges for any actor playing a 19th-century character, whether it's Ellen Page or Emma Thompson. (...)
Perhaps there is something else going on with the casting of Page. Film producers want stars that can "open" a film, and it's a hard fact of movie-making that economics are important. Even if you want to make the film with a little-known but brilliant British actress, if no one will give you the money to do that, then the film just doesn't get made. But having said that, luckily Ellen Page is very much up to the task, as well as being a name.
Search
Labels
- Advert (4)
- Agnes Grey (329)
- Alert (1606)
- Anne Brontë (558)
- Art-Exhibitions (956)
- Arthur Bell Nicholls (28)
- At The... (11)
- Audio-Radio (573)
- Biography (352)
- Books (3954)
- Branwell Brontë (362)
- Brentë Society (1)
- Brontë 200 (395)
- Brontë Birthplace (12)
- Brontë Parsonage Museum (1562)
- Brontë Society (528)
- Brontëana (761)
- Brontëites (1900)
- Brussels (274)
- Charlotte Brontë (902)
- Comics (414)
- Contest (34)
- Cottage Poems (8)
- Dance (352)
- Elizabeth Gaskell (237)
- Ellen Nussey (12)
- Emily Brontë (1031)
- Fake News & Blunders (130)
- Fiction (406)
- Haworth (1758)
- Humour (359)
- Illustrations (160)
- In Memoriam (3)
- In the News (1159)
- Ireland (77)
- Jane Eyre (7419)
- Jounals (2)
- Journals (519)
- Juvenilia (291)
- Maria Branwell Brontë (23)
- Mary Taylor (63)
- Messages from BB (107)
- Movies-DVD-TV (4484)
- Music (2190)
- New Releases (7)
- Opera (231)
- Patrick Brontë (206)
- Penzance (15)
- Poetry (833)
- Red House (54)
- References (2698)
- Reminder (122)
- Review (138)
- Scarborough (79)
- Scholar (1172)
- Sequels and Retellings (1111)
- Shirley (268)
- Software (16)
- Talks (1411)
- Teatre (3)
- The Professor (135)
- The Tenant of Wildfell Hall (514)
- Theatre (3195)
- Thornton (151)
- Top Withens (91)
- Translations (508)
- Unfinished Novels (9)
- Victorian Era (379)
- Villette (555)
- Websites & Apps (194)
- Weirdo (660)
- Wide Sargasso Sea (997)
- Wuthering Heights (6793)
Recent Posts
Old Labels
Blog Archive
Other BrontëBlogs
-
Octavia Cox on Anne Brontë and sea symbolism - It has been said that what the Yorkshire moors were to Emily Brontë the sea was to her sister Anne – a soul-enlivening physical space and an inspiring im...3 days ago
-
Anne Bronte’s ‘Night’: A Poetic Snapshot - Anne Brontë was one of the greatest novelists of the nineteenth century; her books Agnes Grey and The Tenant Of Wildfell Hall deserve to be ranked alongsid...4 days ago
-
2024年ブロンテ・デイ公開講座についてのご案内 - 2024年ブロンテ・デイ公開講座を6月1日(土)14:00より早稲田大学戸山キャンパス38号館AV教室1にて開催いたします。詳細はこちら をご覧ください。ブロンテ文学に興味がある方であればどなたでも受講できます。受講料は無料です。 お申し込みはこちらからお願いいたします(受付期間4月26日〜5月24日)。...2 weeks ago
-
Interesting side over the Haworth Old Post Office, with beautiful photo's. - *facebook/theoldpostofficehaworth*: Restoring the old Brontë Post Office to its Victorian glory... This is the original location where Emily Brontë pass...5 weeks ago
-
Storytime for Grownups - a podcast reading of Jane Eyre - I recently received an email from Faith Moore, creator and podcaster of Storytime for Grownups, who is releasing a free podcast audiobook version of Jane...2 months ago
-
Celebrating Anne Brontë - Wishing a happy belated birthday to Anne Brontë, born on 17th January 1820 in Thornton. She was an English novelist and poet and her works include the prot...3 months ago
-
Goodbye, Jane - As two wonderful years come to an end, Piper and Lillian reflect on what we've learned from Jane Eyre. Thank you for joining us on this journey. Happy...3 months ago
-
The Calderdale Windfarm - *The Calderdale Windfarm* Sixty-five turbines, each one of them forty metres taller than Blackpool Tower! All of them close by Top Withens. This is what ...3 months ago
-
Hathersage in the Hope Valley, in the Dark Peak, Derbyshire with Charlotte Bronte - July 1845 - The vicarage at the side of St Michael and all Angels church Hathersage. Charlotte would have been the mistress of this house had she married the Reveren...4 months ago
-
Hello! - This is our new post website for The Anne Brontë Society. We are based in Scarborough UK, and are dedicated to preserving Anne’s work, memory, and legacy. ...9 months ago
-
Final thoughts. - Back from honeymoon and time for Charlotte to admire her beautiful wedding day bonnet before storing it carefully away in the parsonage. After 34 days...1 year ago
-
Charlotte Bronte and the Great Exhibition of 1851 - A Great Exhibition at the Crystal Palace, celebrating industrial advances, had been promoted from July 1949 by Prince Albert and Sir Henry Cole, the sam...1 year ago
-
Ambrotipia – Tesori dal Brontë Parsonage Museum - Continua la collaborazione tra The Sisters’ Room e il Brontë Parsonage Museum. Vi mostriamo perciò una serie di contenuti speciali, scelti e curati dire...2 years ago
-
-
ERROR: Tried to load source page, but remote server reported "500 Internal Server Error". -2 years ago
-
Novedad: Cartas olvidadas de Jane Eyre y Anna Karenina - Hola a todos, Justamente hoy sale a la venta un libro relativamente relacionado con Jane Eyre y no quería dejar pasar la oportunidad de dároslo a conocer. ...2 years ago
-
-
-
Livre «Quel Brontë êtes-vous ?» - Un nouveau livre en français au sujet des Brontë est paru le 20 février 2020 aux éditions Librinova : Quel Brontë êtes-vous ? par Anna Feissel-Leibovici. ...4 years ago
-
Two New Anne Brontë 200 Books – Out Now! - Anne was a brilliant writer (as well as a talented artist) so it’s great to see some superb new books…4 years ago
-
Brontë in media - Wist u dat? In de film ‘The Guernsey Literary & Potato Peel Pie Society’ gebaseerd op de gelijknamige briefroman, schrijft hoofdrolspeelster Juliet Ashto...4 years ago
-
Researching Emily Brontë at Southowram - A couple of weeks ago I took a wander to the district of Southowram, just a few miles across the hills from Halifax town centre, yet feeling like a vil...5 years ago
-
Handwriting envy - The opening facsimile of Charlotte Brontë’s hand for the opening of the novel is quite arresting. A double underlining emphasises with perfect clarity tha...5 years ago
-
Link: After that dust-up, first editions are dusted off for Brontë birthday - The leaden skies over Haworth could not have been more atmospheric as they set to work yesterday dusting off the first editions of Emily Brontë at the begi...6 years ago
-
Page wall post by Clayton Walker - Clayton Walker added a new photo to The Brontë Society's timeline.6 years ago
-
Page wall post by La Sezione Italiana della Brontë Society - La Sezione Italiana della Brontë Society: La Casa editrice L'Argolibro e la Sezione Italiana della Brontë Society in occasione dell'anno bicentenario dedi...6 years ago
-
Html to ReStructuredText-converter - Wallflux.com provides a rich text to reStructredText-converter. Partly because we use it ourselves, partly because rst is very transparent in displaying wh...6 years ago
-
Display Facebook posts in a WordPress widget - You can display posts from any Facebook page or group on a WordPress blog using the RSS-widget in combination with RSS feeds from Wallflux.com: https://www...6 years ago
-
charlottebrontesayings: To Walk Invisible - The Brontë Sisters,... - charlottebrontesayings: *To Walk Invisible - The Brontë Sisters, this Christmas on BBC* Quotes from the cast on the drama: *“I wanted it to feel...7 years ago
-
thegrangersapprentice: Reading Jane Eyre for English class.... - thegrangersapprentice: Reading Jane Eyre for English class. Also, there was a little competition in class today in which my teacher asked some really spe...7 years ago
-
5. The Poets’ Jumble Trail Finds - Yesterday I had the pleasure of attending with some friends a jumble trail in which locals sold old – and in some instances new – bits and bobs from their ...8 years ago
-
How I Met the Brontës - My first encounter with the Brontës occurred in the late 1990’s when visiting a bookshop offering a going-out-of -business sale. Several books previously d...9 years ago
-
-
Radio York - I was interviewed for the Paul Hudson Weather Show for Radio York the other day - i had to go to the BBC radio studios in Blackburn and did the interview...10 years ago
-
-
Short excerpt from an interview with Mia Wasikowska on the 2011 Jane Eyre - I really like what she says about the film getting Jane's age right. Jane's youth really does come through in the film.13 years ago
-
Emily Brontë « joignait à l’énergie d’un homme la simplicité d’un enfant ». - *Par **T. de Wyzewa.* C’est M. Émile Montégut qui, en même temps qu’il révélait au public français la vie et le génie de Charlotte Brontë, a le premier cit...13 years ago
-
CELEBRATION DAY - MEDIA RELEASE February 2010 For immediate release FREE LOCAL RESIDENTS’ DAY AT NEWLY REFURBISHED BRONTË MUSEUM This image shows the admission queue on the...14 years ago
-
Poetry Day poems - This poem uses phrases and lines written by visitors at the Bronte Parsonage Museum to celebrate National Poetry Day 2009, based on words chosen from Emily...14 years ago
-
The Secret Diaries of Charlotte Bronte - Firstly, I would like to thank the good people at Avon- Harper Collins for sending me a review copy of Syrie James' new book, The Secret Diaries of Charlot...14 years ago
Podcasts
-
With... Adam Sargant - It's our last episode of series 1!!! Expect ghost, ghouls and lots of laughs as we round off the series with Adam Sargant, AKA Haunted Haworth. We'll be...1 week ago
Subscriptions
Brontë Parsonage X
Brontë Studies X
Other Stuff
Click to join BRONTE
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 Unported License.
Site archived by the British Library - UK Web Archiving Consortium
How insecure my countrymen and women are! When it comes to anything earlier than the 20th century there really is so little to choose among any of the Anglophone cultures that the quality of the actor will dominate. Come to think of it this is sometimes even true for contemporary Britain (e.g., Bridget Jones Diaries).
ReplyDeleteI have to say it makes me all the more interested in the film. I am sure she will do an excellent job.
I don't think it has anything to do with insecurity. I think the British are very protective of their great works and their accent(s) and tend to look at this kind of thing hesitantly at first. Later, if the actor in question did a good job, they don't complain much.
ReplyDeleteMany British actors cross the pond as well and it's very rarely - if ever - that anyone questions their accent, origins.
Hopefully Ellen Page - if she does play Jane Eyre eventually - will certainly make a good job. The role demands it.
I loved Ellen Page in Juno, but it's hard to imagine her as Jane Eyre. Maybe in a modernized version, à la Clueless:
ReplyDelete"There was, like, totally no possibility of taking a walk that day, or whatever..."
To be honest, Ruth Wilson will always be Jane Eyre to me now.
The OP: Beatrix Potter; Jane Austen; all three Bronte sisters at point were set to be played by non-Brits; Catherine Earnshaw (thank goodness that actress has dropped out - a horrendous accent in all her 'Brit' roles), and now Jane Eyre. The latter being a BBC film production which makes partial use of the license fee: I'd say we have every right to voice our grievances.
ReplyDeleteRob Hardy - ha! I loved your brand new first line for Jane Eyre.
ReplyDeleteBrontë novels - with the possible exception of Wuthering Heights - seem to be harder to update than Jane Austen's, though.
I think Ruth Wilson is also the actress with more in common with my idea of the actual Jane Eyre.
Tattycoram - But what do you think, for instance, of Jennifer Ehle playing Elizabeth Bennet? Obviously, if an actress's accent comes naturally she will be able to focus on other stuff but if she's a good actress or well-directed the accent thing can be got over and the acting become natural and likable for the natives.
Cristina: Jennifer Ehle has a British mother; her accent in the early 90's - judging from interviews on TV and the stage - was distinctly an English one. It's a testament to her talent and background that - although she now has an US accent - she can switch between both effortlessly.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q4PZpKNBZSQ
What gets me is that Brit actresses - from the get go - are looked over for mainstream/pretty actresses - or the one that's making headlines at the moment.
If there's an actress with the film, television and stage talent and experience of Ehle, then by all means I can't gripe - but instead we get the Natalie Portmans, Ellen Pages, Scarlett Johansson's (again, she leads the 'cue' to play Mary Queen of Scots) and Evan Rachel Woods of this world.
Regarding Ruth Wilson: The chemistry with Toby Stephens made that Jane Eyre; I'm not a massive fan of the overall production, but Ruth was extremely good. Imagine if they'd cast someone like Ellen Page and overlooked Ruth?
Oops - I didn't know about Jennifer Ehle's British mother.
ReplyDeleteI think it depends on the intention of the production. The BBC opted for Ruth Wilson - a British and virtually unknown actress - and they got good results. But big names seem to lull them into a false (?) sense of security, and American actress are mostly better known internationally, aren't they?
Still I say, if the actress in question is a GOOD actress and proves it in the film then I have nothing against it.