Podcasts

  • S4 E8: With... Rebecca Marks - For the final episode of series 4, Sam and Mia are joined by historian, author and content creator Dr Rebecca Marks! Rebecca holds a Master's in Art Hist...
    1 month ago

Thursday, October 01, 2026

Thursday, October 01, 2026 7:34 am by Cristina in , , , , ,    No comments
Warwickshire World has another review of Underdog: The Other Other Brontë.
Anne-marie Greene’s direction gives Sarah Gordon’s 2024 already feisty modern-day revision of the Brontë myth a quick-witted flair. Much of this is due to the clever, knowing portrayal of Charlotte by Alice Scott. She is a pink-haired, elfin dominatrix of the family. Her determination to place herself at the top of the literary tree is expressed by frequent asides through the fourth wall, which draws us onto her side while at the same time slightly repelling us at the unfairness of her treatment of her sisters, Anne in particular. We forgive her, up to a point, partly because of her sparky charm and her knowing comments about the (still) patriarchal publishing game, but also because we buy into her idea that without her there would have been no Brontës. Even Emily, passionately, often angrily played by Nicole Cortese, is sidelined by her.
And what of poor Anne? Anne, the nice one, Anne the modest, self-effacing one who suspends her literary ambitions to become a governess, one of the lowest rungs of the Victorian social ladder, where she is bullied and humiliated by her employers and their nasty children. Somehow, she turns this unhappy experience into a scathing condemnation of abuse within marriage which was revolutionary in her day, and hits the jackpot with her book sales.
But in order to succeed the sisters had to pretend to be men, otherwise they would have been dismissed as mere ‘women writers.’ But this brings a conundrum. By pretending to be men they are, in a sense, beating the men at their own game and are somewhat protected by the mask, provided their true identities remain secret. Once they are revealed they are subject to the very condemnation they challenged in spite of, and because of, their success.
Sarah Gordon’s play doesn't delve too deeply into the books themselves; rather it is the Brontë myth that is explored and its status as a repudiation of patriarchy. Even Branwell Brontë (Connor Bailey), their wayward, drunken brother, who aspired to be a painter though he lacked the talent, is somehow portrayed as a victim of this London-based snobbery. Ironically by working together to create the image of the Bell brothers,  partly in order to protect him from full knowledge of himself, the sisters cannot help but buy into that snobbery.
Charlotte tries to rip the façade off the dominant ideology of the time by making herself into a literary superstar and using her fame to overturn the orthodoxy. It is self-conscious promotion with its roots in the past and its flower very much in the present. The cast, including an excellent ensemble, have great fun with it, playing with a punk / Gen Z theme. The performances are top-notch throughout, the three sisters well balanced in their characters, Charlotte as the apex of a triangle that could only function as a collective. (Nick Le Mesurier)
Still on stage, Sussex World features Evie Depledge, who's currently playing Jane in Conn Artists' Jane Eyre.
“I've always loved the book. I love English literature. I first read Jane Eyre at high school when I was 11 or 12 or 13 and I just loved it. I'm very much an Austen and Bronte girl. I read all of them but I always remember Jane Eyre struck me as such a fantastic heroine.
“I think she has such a strong will. She is so passionate and so determined to keep to her values and her morality and her desire to do what is right. I think that fascinated me as a child. You often see in people their kindness or their bravery and she's kind and brave but I think the main thing for Jane is doing what is right. She is willing sometimes to make people a little bit upset but it comes from a place not of weakness; it comes from a place of wanting to do the right thing. I love her strength and I think it is that core that really attracted me to Jane as a person. And I'm really interested to see what resonates with me now. I read it as a young person, and to come back to it again now it's interesting to rediscover it and to see what really resonates now.” (Phil Hewitt)
QBurgh reviews the novel The Lost Brontë by Catherine Friend.
This time of year, you may come to crave dark, spooky stories, and “The Last Brontë” fits those needs perfectly with its Gothic deliciousness. Think: Daphne du Maurier-type, stormy-night squirms with a dangerously chaste, sweetly romantic girl-meets-girl twist for fun.
If it’s been awhile since you’ve read a Gothic novel, you’re in for a nice reminder of why you love them here. You can almost tick off the must-haves: a novel like this is nothing without a foreboding stone manor with damp walls; stone steps to a dank basement; a mysterious portrait; and a nearby bog, and author Catherine Friend gives readers every one of them. You’d be disappointed if there was no ghost, wouldn’t you? Ha. You can practically feel the cold blow through the attic, right? Yeah, it’s that kind of book.If you’re a fan of the Brontës, you’ll like this novel. If you love Gothic mysteries or Victorian romances, ditto. “The Lost Brontë” is good, no lie. (Terri Schlichenmeyer)
The University Echo wonders, 'Are the Books Really Better than the Movies?'
Nowadays, there are plenty of adaptations that blatantly acknowledge the literary classic that it is based on. In just February of this year, a movie adaptation of Emily Brontë’s “Wuthering Heights” hit theatres. [...]
The question becomes, are these adaptations a sign of a lack of creativity or is Hollywood’s ability to take literary classics unknown or disliked by the younger generations a show of creativity and innovative thinking? I’m not quite sure.
UTC junior Lexie Jones, a history and anthropology double major, gave her perspective on the question: “I don’t think it's a lack of creativity. Like ‘Wuthering Heights.’ I haven’t watched the new movie but it was a way to draw in people who probably would have never read the book.”
The movie adaptations may become a way to draw interest from our generation. The prospect of reading the classics, to most, might seem boring and a waste of time, especially if it has nothing to do with your major. The most popular book genres right now are romance or ‘romantasy,’ a term coined by TikTok. Fantasy, thrillers, science fiction and horror are the runner-ups. Classic fiction wasn’t really high on the list.
“Wuthering Heights” was advertised with phrases such as “drive me mad,” “come undone,” and "inspired by the greatest love story of all time.” The movie starred well-known actors Margot Robbie as Catherine Earnshaw and Jacob Elordi as Heathcliff, and was released on Valentine’s Day. The marketing was directed towards the generation that made romance the most popular book genre.
The movie only covered about half of the original novel, though. Watchers who were enamored by the love story on the screen can continue the story by returning to the novel. Adults who may have never considered opening the novel might just read it now, or at least stop and purchase it at the book store. (Haley Goodfriend)
Den of Geek lists '15 Movie Characters That Look Nothing Like Their Descriptions' and one of them is Heathcliff.
Heathcliff Was Described as Dark-Skinned
Emily Brontë repeatedly gives Heathcliff a dark complexion and describes him as “a dark-skinned gipsy in aspect.” Laurence Olivier’s 1939 Wuthering Heights became one of the character’s most famous screen versions despite looking very different. (Fernanda Arnaud)
El diario de Madrid (Spain) discusses Wuthering Heights and Emerald Fennell's take on the novel.
Hace poco inicié la relectura de la novela de Emily Brontë, Cumbres borrascosas, porque tenía una deuda con el libro. La primera vez que lo leí fue hace veinticinco años y siento que no fue la mejor lectura, pues mi habilidad como lector aún no se había desarrollado para obras como esta. El refrán «cada libro tiene su tiempo» es, por lo menos en mi caso, cierto.
Otro detonante que anticipó mi relectura fue la insípida, anodina, insulsa, adormecida, formulaica y pobrísima versión cinematográfica de Emerald Fennell sobre Cumbres borrascosas. El desarrollo psicológico de sus personajes y la atmósfera de la película se asemejan al ámbito de Cincuenta sombras de Grey: buscan desfogar un deseo carnal sin ningún tipo de composición narrativa que sustente la pasión entre los protagonistas. Quería quitarme ese amargo sabor.
El problema no es que Emerald Fennell haya cambiado la historia; desde el título entrecomillado se puede deducir que la película busca alejarse por completo de la obra literaria: omitió a Lockwood, quien se convierte en el repositorio de la historia, e ignoró la facultad narrativa de Nelly Dean. Estas licencias que se tomó Fennell no aportan valor a la cinta, sino que reflejan el afán de contar una historia distinta que no logra trascender y se queda en un vacuo entretenimiento de Hollywood.
El problema no es que Emerald Fennell haya cambiado la historia; desde el título entrecomillado se deduce que la película busca distanciarse de la obra literaria: omitió a Lockwood —el marco receptor de la historia— y despojó a Nelly Dean de su compleja ambigüedad como narradora no fiable, reduciéndola a un mero detonante de hechos trágicos. Además, en el filme es el Sr. Earnshaw quien termina ebrio e hipotecando sus propiedades hasta perderlas a manos de Heathcliff; sin embargo, en la novela original esta ruina personal y financiera recae enteramente en su hijo Hindley Earnshaw. Estas licencias no aportan valor a la cinta, sino que reflejan el afán de contar una historia efectista que se queda en un vacuo entretenimiento de Hollywood.
Al comprender las circunstancias de Heathcliff, deducimos que su comportamiento (cuestionable desde la moral) es el resultado de un contexto hostil: es un huérfano pauperizado y maltratado tanto por su padre como por su hermano adoptivos. Como bien señaló Karl Marx: «No es la conciencia del hombre la que determina su ser, sino, por el contrario, el ser social es el que determina su conciencia». Sin embargo, bajo la mirada moralizante y burguesa de la narradora Nelly, la personalidad de Heathcliff no es responsabilidad de una estructura social, sino estrictamente del individuo. De manera similar, la contemporaneidad —bajo el espejismo de que «el pobre es pobre porque quiere»— traslada la responsabilidad de un sistema de privilegios e imperfecto, hacia las clases bajas, culpándolas de su propia condición y favoreciendo el desarrollo de trastornos como la depresión y la ansiedad, así como fenómenos psicosociales de indefensión aprendida y vergüenza social interiorizada. ¿Podría considerarse a Heathcliff, entonces, como una advertencia de las pasiones y grietas que genera una estructura ciega a la salud mental del otro? (Juan Sebastián Sánchez) (Translation)

0 comments:

Post a Comment